11-29-2020  6:16 pm   •   PDX and SEA Weather
MLK Breakfast 2021 Save the Date
By Arashi Young | The Skanner News
Published: 05 May 2016

The ACLU of Oregon recently released a report, “Roadblocks to Reform,” which details the extensive influence of district attorneys, the highest ranking prosecutors.

In each county, this one lawyer manages the staff of prosecutors who have the power to file criminal charges, bring evidence to grand juries and determine when an alleged crime falls under mandatory minimum sentencing.

David Rogers, the executive director of the ACLU of Oregon said Oregonians don’t see district attorneys as accountable publicly elected officers -- and believes that needs to change.

“We need to… create mechanisms for the public to engage the district attorneys as the elected officials that they are,” Rogers said.

The report studied district attorney elections in Oregon from 2004 to 2014, covering six election cycles. During this period of time there were 111 DA races, but only 24 of these elections were contested. Nearly 8 out of every 10 district attorneys faced no opposition on the ballot.

New district attorneys are also appointed by the governor when the previous DA retires. 17 of the 36 acting DAs were initially appointed by a governor. Most of these appointments are assistant district attorneys who have been working with previous DA. The report questions whether this promoting from within keeps the office from embracing criminal justice reforms.

Rogers told The Skanner News that district attorneys have the power to influence racial disparities in the criminal justice system through their use of mandatory minimum sentencing and the prosecution of low-level crimes.

With the increased use of mandatory minimum sentences, there has been a corresponding rise in the amount of plea bargains used by defendants to avoid the worst case scenario of the mandatory minimum. According to Rogers, nearly 90 percent of cases never go to trial as defendants make plea agreements.

The ACLU report outlines how district attorneys can choose to prosecute low level offenses or choose to put defendants into criminal diversion programs. A number of reform minded DAs were highlighted in the report such as Prosecuting Attorney Dan Satterberg representing King County in Seattle and John Chisolm, the district attorney of Milwaukee County in Wisconsin.

The MacArthur Foundation Racial and Ethnic Disparities report on Multnomah County found disproportionate treatment of African Americans at every level of the criminal justice system. Black people are charged with low level offenses like trespass, disorderly conduct and littering at three to five times the rate of White people.

“Right now, Black people are being charged with low level offenses at seriously disproportionate rates -- at much higher level than White people,” Rogers said. “The district attorney’s office has the discretion to stop doing that.”

The report recommended four strategies to reform the criminal justice system through the district attorney’s office:

  • To educate the public about the role of district attorneys and prosecutors.
  • To encourage more engagement between district attorneys and voters.
  • To cultivate district attorney candidates who want to reform the criminal justice system
  • To encourage the Governor to appoint reform minded district attorneys.

Kristen Grainger, the communications director for Governor Kate Brown, said the governor is very concerned about the overrepresentation of racial minorities, particularly Black men, in the criminal justice system.

Grainger said that Governor Brown has had the opportunity to appoint only one district attorney since taking office and a lot of thought goes into the process of choosing a new DA.

“In selecting district attorneys, when the occasion infrequently arises, Governor Brown makes decisions on a case by case basis. She seeks a diverse pool of applicants and selects the person she believes is best suited to serve that community’s needs,” Grainger told The Skanner News.

Kevin Neely, the spokesperson for the Oregon District Attorneys Association, said there is another reason DAs are often unopposed in general elections and are generally promoted from within:  there are very few qualified candidates.

“This is complex work that requires a very advanced degree of specialization and it shouldn’t come as a shock to anyone that a sitting prosecutor is the most qualified for the job,” Neely said.

Unlike city council members or state legislators, district attorneys need to be lawyers who specialize in criminal law. In addition, the contract from the state is often less than what a lawyer could earn as a prosecutor or defense attorney.

Neely disputes the report’s assertion that district attorneys are not engaged with citizens and says they are focused on public safety. As for the question of reforming the criminal justice system, Neely says those policies come from Oregon voters.

“Most of the significant policies that have come down over the last twenty years in Oregon, related to public safety, have been enacted by the voters,” he said. “The district attorneys have implemented the will of the voters.”

Recently Published by The Skanner News

  • Default
  • Title
  • Date
  • Random
  • Wisconsin recount of its presidential results on Sunday, confirmed that Democrat Joe Biden won the state by more than 20,600 votes...   MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Wisconsin finished a recount of its presidential results on Sunday, confirming Democrat Joe Biden's victory over President Donald Trump in the key battleground state. Trump vowed to challenge the outcome in court even before the recount concluded. Dane County was the second and last county to finish its recount, reporting a 45-vote gain for Trump. Milwaukee County, the state's other big and overwhelmingly liberal county targeted in a recount that Trump paid for, reported its results Friday, a 132-vote gain for Biden. Taken together, the two counties barely budged Biden's winning margin of about 20,600 votes.  “As we have said, the recount only served to reaffirm Joe Biden’s victory in Wisconsin," Danielle Melfi, who led Biden's campaign in Wisconsin, said in a statement to The Associated Press. Trump tweets he will sue With no precedent for overturning a result as large as Biden's, Trump was widely expected to head to court once the recount was finished. His campaign challenged thousands of absentee ballots during the recount, and even before it was complete, Trump tweeted that he would sue. “The Wisconsin recount is not about finding mistakes in the count, it is about finding people who have voted illegally, and that case will be brought after the recount is over, on Monday or Tuesday,” Trump tweeted on Saturday. “We have found many illegal votes. Stay tuned!” Trump campaign officials didn't immediately respond to AP requests for comment on Sunday. The deadline to certify the vote is Tuesday. Certification is done by the Democratic chair of the Wisconsin Election Commission, which is bipartisan.  Drop boxes "illegal" suit says The Wisconsin Voters Alliance, a conservative group, has already filed a lawsuit against state election officials seeking to block certification of the results. It makes many of the claims Trump is expected to make. Gov. Tony Evers’ attorneys have asked the state Supreme Court to dismiss the suit. Evers, a Democrat, said the complaint is a “mishmash of legal distortions” that uses factual misrepresentations in an attempt to take voting rights away from millions of Wisconsin residents.  Another suit filed over the weekend by Wisconsin resident Dean Mueller argues that ballots placed in drop boxes are illegal and must not be counted. Trump lawsuits have failed Trump’s attorneys have complained about absentee ballots where voters identified themselves as “indefinitely confined,” allowing them to cast an absentee ballot without showing a photo ID; ballots that have a certification envelope with two different ink colors, indicating a poll worker may have helped complete it; and absentee ballots that don’t have a separate written record for its request, such as in-person absentee ballots. Election officials in the two counties counted those ballots during the recount, but marked them as exhibits at the request of the Trump campaign.  Trump’s campaign has already failed elsewhere in court without proof of widespread fraud, which experts widely agree doesn’t exist. Trump legal challenges have failed in Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada and Pennsylvania.
    Read More
  • Pennsylvania justices also remarked on the lawsuit's staggering demand that an entire election be overturned retroactively. “They have failed to allege that even a single mail-in ballot was fraudulently cast or counted,” Justice David Wecht wrote in a concurring opinion
    Read More
  • The number of COVID-19 related hospitalizations also continues to surge with 529 people hospitalized — a 209% increase since the start of the month
    Read More
  • Of the 33,035 vehicle stops Portland police made in 2019, 18% were for Black drivers and 65% were for white drivers. White people make up 75.1% of the population, while Black people make up 5.8%
    Read More
  • Oregon wholesale tree farmers and small cut-your-own lots are reporting strong demand and seeing more people earlier than ever
    Read More
  • The police bureau uses a complicated methodology in reporting data
    Read More
  • Groups representing Oregon foodservice and lodging businesses had asked the judge to modify the governor’s order
    Read More