04-23-2018  2:50 am      •     
The Skanner Report
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

NEWS BRIEFS

Think & Drink with Rinku Sen and Mary Li

Event takes place Wednesday, May 16, at Alberta Rose Theater ...

April 24 is Voter Registration Deadline for May 15 Primary Election

Tuesday, April 24, is voter registration and party choice deadline for May 15 Primary Election ...

Portland Libraries Celebrate National Poetry Month

April poetry events and recommended reading from Multnomah County libraries ...

PCRI Launches the Pathway 1000 Implementation Plan

Pathway 1000 a bold and ambitious 10-year displacement mitigation initiative ...

AG Rosenblum Launches New Resource on Oregon’s New Gun Safety Laws

One-page handout aims to educate Oregonians about the new law ...

U.S. & WORLD NEWS

OPINION

The Skanner News Endorsements for May 2018 Elections

Read The Skanner News' endorsements for Multnomah County, Portland City Council and more ...

Will HUD Secretary Ben Carson Enforce the Fair Housing Act?

Julianne Malveaux questions HUD Secretary Ben Carson’s ability to enforce the Fair Housing Act ...

Waiting While Black in Philadelphia Can Get You Arrested

Reggie Shuford on the daily indignities African-Americans face in Philadelphia and around the country ...

Black People Must Vote or Reap the Consequences

Jeffrey Boney on the importance of voting in the Black community ...

AFRICAN AMERICANS IN THE NEWS

ENTERTAINMENT

By The Skanner News

Was Edward Snowden a hero or a traitor?  That is the question the media, the public and elected officials have debated ever since Snowden released classified information about the United States' efforts to monitor its own citizens.

But on Thursday, the debate got more interesting when representatives from the National Security Agency -- the organization Snowden leaked information about -- the Pentagon and the American Civil Liberties Union informally debated the issue in public.

"I think he did this country a service," Anthony Romero, executive director of the ACLU said regarding Snowden. "I have not said that publicly until this point. I think he did this country a service by starting a debate that was anemic, that was left to government officials where people did not understand fully what was happening."

Romero's animated admission came at a Thursday panel at the Aspen Security Forum.

While the ACLU leader was making his case for Snowden, Jane Harman, a former congresswoman who initially approved the program that Snowden leaked, was seen shaking her head.

In response to Romero, Jeh Charles Johnson, the former general counsel for the Department of Defense, said what Snowden did sent "a bad message."

"I think it is a bad message for us to send to people who decide to take the law into their own hands that they are doing a public service," Johnson said.

Johnson argued that the courts are where debate over national surveillance programs belongs. In response, Romero said Snowden is the reason the ACLU can now get in front of a court to argue the necessity of certain aspects of government surveillance.

"I think our country is better as a result of the revelations of Mr. Snowden," Romero said, concluding his argument.

"That is anarchy," Johnson responded.

Raj De, NSA general counsel, said he believes the NSA and the intelligence community should be as transparent as possible, but with the caveat that transparency is "consistent with our need to protect national security."




Regarding the phone metadata storage program, he said that is "strictly controlled ... to query the data, one has to have a reasonable, articuable suspicion that a particular selector -- which is a phone number -- has a tie to a specific terrorist group that is identified in a court order."

Snowden, a former National Security Agency contractor, leaked classified NSA documents to the media, sparking worldwide controversy over U.S. surveillance programs.

Since leaking the information, Snowden has been a man without a country. He has received asylum offers from Venezuela, Bolivia and Nicaragua, but remains stuck in Moscow's international airport because the United States has revoked his travel documents.

During the debate, Harman interjected to play the role of mediator, skating the line between the two opposing sides. The former congresswoman did, however, argue for Snowden to return to the United States.

"That this guy needs to seek public asylum from other countries because he would be persecuted here is totally nonsense," Harman said. "A lot of Americans support what he did, he should come back and face a fair trial. He's been charged but he hasn't been convicted."

Harman acknowledged the Snowden affair has sparked a badly-needed national debate about the country's clandestine data-collection programs. But she said that did not justify Snowden's leaking of information that could compromise sources and methods.

In June, federal prosecutors charged Snowden with espionage and theft of government property, according to a criminal complaint unsealed in U.S. District Court in Virginia on Friday.

CNN's Carol Cratty contributed to this report.

Oregon Lottery
Calendar

Photo Gallery

Photos and slide shows of local events

The Skanner Report